Aroar-a-saurus vs Molasses Sloth: Award-Winning Teether Rattles
By Mary Meyer Stuffed Toys & Baby Gifts | Published: 2026-11-01
Category: Product Reviews
Compare the Taggies Crinkle Me Aroar-a-saurus and Molasses Sloth Teether Rattle on size, texture, and teething features to choose the right award-winning baby teether.
Quick answer
Choose the Taggies Crinkle Me Aroar-a-saurus if you want a compact, crinkle-textured square that soothes sore gums through sound and touch; choose the Taggies Molasses Sloth Teether Rattle if you prefer a soft, huggable sloth with a silicone teether and an internal rattle for combined comfort and distraction.
Size and shape: square vs. sloth
The Aroar-a-saurus is a 6×6-inch square, making it easy to tuck into a diaper bag or stroller pocket. Its flat shape lies against the gums for targeted chewing. The Molasses Sloth is a 5-inch plush, so it offers a rounder, more cuddly form that a baby can grip with both hands. Neither size is inherently better—the square suits focused teething moments, while the sloth suits longer comfort sessions.
Texture and sensory features
The Aroar-a-saurus is built around crinkle fabric and satin tags, which provide auditory feedback and tactile exploration. The Molasses Sloth combines incredibly soft plush, a silicone teether on the outside, and a rattle inside. If your baby is soothed by sound and rubbing tags, the crinkle square may hold attention longer. If your baby prefers to hug and mouth a soft toy, the sloth’s plush body and silicone teether may be more engaging.
Awards and age considerations
Both toys are finalists for Progressive Preschool Awards in the Best Infant Development category—the Aroar-a-saurus in 2022 and the Molasses Sloth in 2019. That recognition suggests they are designed with infant development in mind, but it does not replace your own observation of what your baby reaches for. The Aroar-a-saurus is excluded from coupons and is final sale, so returns may be limited; the sloth has no such restriction listed.
Key trade-offs
- Sensory feedback: The Aroar-a-saurus relies on crinkle fabric and satin tags for sound and touch, while the Molasses Sloth uses a silicone teether and internal rattle. If your baby needs strong auditory feedback, the crinkle square may be more effective.
- Comfort vs. compactness: The sloth’s plush body is huggable but bulkier; the 6×6-inch square is flatter and easier to pack. Consider where you will use the toy most—at home or on the go.
- Purchase risk: The Aroar-a-saurus is final sale and excluded from coupons; the Molasses Sloth has no such restrictions listed. If you like the option to return, the sloth may be the safer choice.
Product facts
- Taggies Molasses Sloth Teether Rattle – 5″: 5-inch soft sloth with silicone teether and internal rattle. Offers both chewing relief and a gentle rattle sound in one plush toy, so it can double as a comfort object.
Taggies Molasses Sloth Teether Rattle – 5″ - Taggies Crinkle Me Aroar-a-saurus – 6×6″: 6×6-inch crinkle square with satin tags; final sale and excluded from coupons. The crinkle and tags provide sensory feedback, but the final-sale policy means you should be confident before buying.
Taggies Crinkle Me Aroar-a-saurus – 6×6″
Which teether rattle fits your baby?
Best for
- Babies who are soothed by crinkle sounds and rubbing satin tags
- Parents who want a flat, packable teether for diaper bags
Not for
- Babies who prefer to hug and mouth a soft plush toy
- Shoppers who want the option to return or use coupons
