Back to Blog
Product Reviews 2026-11-16 Mary Meyer Stuffed Toys & Baby Gifts 8 views

Marshmallow Junior Lamb vs Putty Cream Unicorn: First Soft Toy

Marshmallow Junior Lamb vs Putty Cream Unicorn: First Soft Toy

Compare the 9-inch Marshmallow Junior Lamb and 10-inch Putty Cream Unicorn for a baby's first soft toy, with honest notes on what the catalog does and doesn't confirm.

Two cuddle toys, two different first-toy jobs

The Marshmallow Junior Lamb and the Putty Cream Unicorn are both soft, both from Mary Meyer, and both sized for small hands. But they are not interchangeable. The lamb is a 9-inch junior plush with beans for weight, while the unicorn is a 10-inch cream plush with etched fur and a machine-washable surface. That difference in fill and care shapes which one makes a better first soft toy, and which one makes a better baby shower gift.

Below, I compare them on the details the catalog actually confirms: size, materials, care, and collection context. I also flag what the records do not confirm, so you can ask the right questions before you buy.

What the catalog confirms about each plush

  • Marshmallow Junior Lamb – 9″: Marshmallow Junior Lamb is 9 inches and contains beans for weight and floppiness. The smaller size and bean fill give it a weighted, floppy feel that some parents prefer for a newborn cuddle toy.
    Marshmallow Junior Lamb – 9″
    Marshmallow Junior Lamb – 9″
  • Putty Cream Unicorn – 10″: Putty Cream Unicorn is 10 inches tall and machine washable, air dry. The larger size and confirmed wash instructions make it easier to keep clean, which matters for a toy that will be handled often.
    Putty Cream Unicorn – 10″
    Putty Cream Unicorn – 10″

Size, fill, and care: the practical differences

Neither toy is described with an age rating in the supplied records, so use the size and construction details to judge what suits your baby.

  • Size: The lamb is 9 inches; the unicorn is 10 inches tall. Both are small enough for a baby to grip, but the unicorn is slightly larger.
  • Fill and feel: The lamb contains beans for weight and floppiness. The unicorn is described as having signature soft etched fur, with no fill details supplied.
  • Care: The unicorn is machine washable and air dry. The lamb's care instructions are not included in the supplied records, so check the hang tag before washing.
  • Style: The lamb is a classic Marshmallow Zoo character; the unicorn is a glam unicorn with a bling alicorn and blush mane and tail.

Which makes a better first soft toy for baby?

If you want a smaller, weighted plush that feels like a little companion, the Marshmallow Junior Lamb is the stronger fit. Its 9-inch size and bean fill are designed for snuggling, and the Marshmallow Zoo line has been a consumer favorite for more than seven years, according to the catalog. That track record does not guarantee your baby will love it, but it does suggest the fabric and construction have held up for many families.

If easy cleaning is your top priority, the Putty Cream Unicorn has the edge. The catalog confirms it is machine washable and air dry, which is a real advantage for a toy that will pick up spills and spit-up. The 10-inch height is still manageable for a baby, and the etched fur gives it a different texture than the lamb's smooth plush.

Baby shower and newborn gifting: matching the plush to the moment

  • For a baby shower gift: The Putty Cream Unicorn's cream color and unicorn design read as a sweet, trendy gift. It is tagged as a trending soft toy, and the 10-inch size looks substantial without being oversized.
  • For a newborn cuddle toy: The Marshmallow Junior Lamb's 9-inch size and bean fill make it a natural first cuddle companion. The lamb theme is classic and neutral, which works well if you do not know the baby's nursery colors.
  • For a gift that will be used often: The unicorn's confirmed machine-wash care makes it the lower-maintenance choice for everyday handling.

What the supplied records do not confirm

The catalog does not list an age range, safety certifications, or specific warnings for either plush. It also does not confirm whether the lamb is machine washable, or whether the unicorn contains beans or other fill. If these details matter to you, check the product tag or contact the store before purchasing. The absence of this information in the records is not a sign that either toy lacks these features; it simply means the catalog entry does not cover them.

Both toys are listed under the board books category on this site, which may be a catalog grouping rather than a statement about the product type. Treat them as soft toys, as described in their titles and details.

A simple way to decide

Choose the Marshmallow Junior Lamb if you want a smaller, weighted plush with a classic lamb design and a proven collection history. Choose the Putty Cream Unicorn if you prefer a slightly larger, machine-washable toy with a more decorative unicorn look. Both are soft, both are from Mary Meyer, and either can serve as a first soft toy or a baby shower plush, as long as you confirm the care and safety details that matter for your family.

Related Articles

Customer Service
Home
Products
Cart
Profile