Two large bears, two very different jobs
Choosing between the Putty Cream Bear XL and the Gingersnap Teddy comes down to size, season, and where the bear will live. The Putty Cream Bear XL is a 36-inch soft toy in a neutral cream color, while the Gingersnap Teddy is a 26-inch holiday bear with a textured plush coat and a plaid scarf. Neither is simply a bigger version of the other—they suit different rooms, occasions, and recipients.
This guide uses the supplied catalog details to help you decide which bear fits your space, your gifting plan, and your tolerance for seasonal decor. We’ll also flag what the catalog does not confirm so you can ask the right questions before you buy.
Size and presence: what 36 inches vs 26 inches means at home
- Putty Cream Bear XL – 36″: Large XL size: 36 inches At 36 inches, this bear is a statement piece. It will dominate a crib corner, a reading nook, or a guest room chair, so measure your intended spot before ordering.

Putty Cream Bear XL – 36″ - Gingersnap Teddy – 26″: 26 inches tall At 26 inches, Gingersnap Teddy is large enough to feel special but easier to tuck under a tree, prop on a bed, or store between seasons.

Gingersnap Teddy – 26″
Color and style: neutral cream vs festive plaid
The Putty Cream Bear XL is described as a cream-colored soft toy bear with a plush appearance, part of the Putty collection. That neutral tone makes it easy to leave out year-round and simple to coordinate with most nursery or living-room palettes.
Gingersnap Teddy has warm brown fur, a textured plush coat, a friendly embroidered face, and a festive plaid scarf. The catalog positions him as a classic holiday bear, which makes him a natural fit for seasonal decorating and holiday gifting. If you want a bear that stays out from November through January, his look does the work; if you prefer one plush for all twelve months, the cream bear is the more versatile choice.
Catalog details that affect the decision
- Putty Cream Bear XL – 36″: Part of the Putty collection If you already own or plan to buy other Putty pieces, this bear keeps the collection consistent in color and style.
- Gingersnap Teddy – 26″: Textured plush fabric for extra-soft snuggling The textured fabric is a sensory detail that may appeal to someone who likes a variety of tactile experiences, though the catalog does not specify age suitability.
Nursery vs holiday display: matching the bear to the room
For a nursery, the Putty Cream Bear XL’s cream color and large size make it a cozy companion that can sit in a corner or on a shelf as a decorative anchor. Its 36-inch height means it will be visible from the crib and can grow with the room’s decor. However, the catalog does not list an age range or safety certifications for this bear, so it is best treated as a decorative plush rather than a sleep or teething item unless you confirm otherwise with the manufacturer.
Gingersnap Teddy’s holiday styling makes him a better fit for a seasonal display—under the tree, on a mantel, or as part of a winter-themed shelf. His 26-inch size is easier to move and store, and the plaid scarf adds a festive touch that feels intentional during the holidays. If you want a bear that doubles as holiday decor and a gift, Gingersnap is the more targeted choice.
Gifting: who each bear suits best
A giant teddy bear gift makes a big impression, and the Putty Cream Bear XL’s 36-inch size delivers that wow factor. It suits a first birthday, a nursery-warming gift, or a “just because” present for someone who loves oversized plush. Because it is neutral, it works for a range of recipients and room styles.
Gingersnap Teddy is a natural holiday gift. The plaid scarf and warm brown fur signal the season, and the 26-inch size is easier to wrap, ship, or carry. If you are buying for a holiday exchange, a December birthday, or a family that decorates for Christmas, this bear fits the moment without overwhelming the recipient’s space.
Side-by-side: key differences at a glance
- Size: Putty Cream Bear XL: 36 inches. Gingersnap Teddy: 26 inches.
- Color and style: Putty Cream Bear XL: cream, plush, part of the Putty collection. Gingersnap Teddy: warm brown textured plush with a festive plaid scarf.
- Best use: Putty Cream Bear XL: year-round nursery decor, oversized cuddling, statement display. Gingersnap Teddy: holiday decorating, seasonal gifting, cozy winter display.
- Storage: Putty Cream Bear XL: large footprint may require a dedicated spot. Gingersnap Teddy: easier to store between seasons.
- Catalog price: Putty Cream Bear XL: USD 99.66 (comparison price USD 151.00). Gingersnap Teddy: USD 41.48 (comparison price USD 61.00).
What the catalog does not confirm
The supplied information does not list an age range, safety warnings, or care instructions for either bear. It also does not confirm whether the plaid scarf on Gingersnap Teddy is removable or whether either bear is machine washable. If these details matter for your household—especially if the bear will be around young children—check the product packaging or contact the store before purchasing.
Neither bear’s catalog entry mentions certifications or testing standards. Treat both as decorative plush unless you verify otherwise. The absence of this information in the catalog is not a claim that the bears lack these features; it simply means you should confirm directly if you need certainty.
How to decide
If you want a year-round nursery companion or a giant teddy bear gift that feels neutral and oversized, choose the Putty Cream Bear XL. Its 36-inch size and cream color make it a lasting presence in a room.
If you are shopping for the holidays, prefer a smaller footprint, or want a bear that looks festive on its own, choose Gingersnap Teddy. His 26-inch size and plaid scarf make him a natural fit for seasonal display and gifting.
Still unsure? Measure the spot where the bear will sit. A 36-inch bear needs about three feet of vertical space and a stable base; a 26-inch bear is more forgiving. Match the bear to the space and the season, and you will pick the one that gets the most use.



