Snuggables Kitty vs Putty Monkey: Choosing a First Soft Toy
By Mary Meyer Stuffed Toys & Baby Gifts | Published: 2026-10-26
Category: Buying Guides
Compare Snuggables Kitty and Putty Monkey to find the right first soft toy for your baby. Get clear decision rules on size, softness, and care.
Quick Answer
For a baby's first soft toy, choose the Snuggables Kitty if you want a compact, huggable pal that's easy for tiny hands to carry. Choose the Putty Monkey if you prefer a slightly larger, modern grey plush with a soft etched texture and easy machine-wash care.
Size and Portability: 14″ vs 12″
The Snuggables Kitty is 14 inches tall, while the Putty Monkey is 12 inches. That two-inch difference may not sound like much, but it affects how a baby grips and carries the toy. The Kitty's just-right size is designed for tiny hands to grasp and take along on adventures, making it a strong companion for toddlers on the move.
The Putty Monkey is a bit shorter, which can make it slightly easier for younger infants to hold. However, both are well within the range of typical first loveys, so the choice often comes down to which shape and feel you prefer.
Softness and Texture: Squishy vs Etched
Softness is a top priority for any plush that will be pressed against a baby's cheek. The Snuggables Kitty features a soft, squishy body that invites hugging and squishing. The Putty Monkey uses soft, etched fabric that feels different to the touch—more textured but still very soft.
If your baby is sensitive to textures, the smoother squishy feel of the Kitty might be more comforting. If you like a little more tactile interest, the Putty Monkey's etched fabric could be a nice sensory experience.
Care and Durability: Machine Washable?
Babies drool, spill, and drag their toys everywhere, so easy cleaning is essential. The Putty Monkey is machine washable and can be air dried, which makes it a practical choice for busy parents. The catalog doesn't specify care instructions for the Snuggables Kitty, so if machine washing is a must-have, the Putty Monkey is the safer bet.
Always check the care tag on any plush before washing, and consider having a backup toy so one can be cleaned while the other is in use.
Decision Rules: Which One to Choose
- Choose Snuggables Kitty if: You want a slightly larger, squishy plush that's designed for tiny hands to carry on adventures. Its soft body is great for hugging during playtime or naps. Check the care tag before washing, as machine-wash instructions aren't listed.
- Choose Putty Monkey if: You prefer a machine-washable plush with a more textured fabric. The 12-inch size is a bit more compact, and the embroidered smile is safe for babies who mouth toys. Air dry after washing to keep the etched fabric soft.
- If you're still unsure: Consider which texture your baby responds to best. If you can, feel both in person or read more reviews to see which one other parents say their babies prefer.
Product Facts
- Snuggables Kitty – 14″: The Snuggables Kitty is 14 inches tall with a soft, squishy body and a lovable expression. Its just-right size makes it easy for tiny hands to grasp and carry, ideal for toddlers who like to bring a friend along.
Snuggables Kitty – 14″ - Putty Monkey – 12″: The Putty Monkey is 12 inches tall with soft, etched fabric, an embroidered smile, and is machine washable. The machine-washable care makes cleanup simple, and the embroidered smile avoids small parts that could detach.
Putty Monkey – 12″
Best Fit for Your Baby
Best for
- Snuggables Kitty: toddlers and young kids who want a huggable, carry-along companion
- Putty Monkey: parents who prioritize easy machine washing and a slightly smaller, textured plush
Not for
- Snuggables Kitty: if you need a machine-washable toy, since care instructions aren't specified
- Putty Monkey: if your baby prefers a smoother, squishier texture over a more textured fabric
