Bears vs Bunnies: Choosing a First Plush for Baby
By Mary Meyer Stuffed Toys & Baby Gifts | Published: 2026-10-29
Category: Comparisons
Deciding between a teddy bear and a bunny for your baby's first plush? We compare size, softness, and style to help you choose the perfect comfort toy.
Quick answer
For most babies, a bunny like the Putty Seafoam Bunny offers a softer, more modern feel, while a teddy like the Snuggables Teddy provides a slightly larger, more classic companion. Choose based on your baby's sensory preferences and the look you want in the nursery.
Size and Portability: Teddy's Advantage
The Snuggables Teddy is 14 inches tall, making it a substantial companion for cuddling and floor play. Its just-right size is perfect for tiny hands to grasp and carry along on adventures, but it may be a bit bulky for a newborn's crib.
The Putty Seafoam Bunny is 11 inches tall, a more compact option that's easier for small babies to hold and for parents to pack in a diaper bag. If portability is a priority, the bunny wins.
Softness and Sensory Appeal: Bunny's Edge
Putty is known for its luxurious, super-soft textured fabric that appeals to modern parents. The seafoam color is on-trend and gender-neutral, making it a stylish choice for nursery decor.
The Snuggables Teddy is described as having a soft, squishy body and lovable expression, but the Putty bunny's fabric is highlighted as exceptionally soft—so soft it makes silk jealous. If ultimate softness is your top priority, the bunny is the way to go.
Style and Theme: Classic vs. Modern
A teddy bear is a timeless classic, often associated with comfort and tradition. It fits seamlessly into any nursery theme and is a familiar choice for grandparents and family heirlooms.
The Putty Seafoam Bunny offers a more contemporary aesthetic with its neutral palette and sophisticated design. It's perfect for parents who want a plush that doubles as a decor piece and aligns with current baby trends.
Trade-offs at a glance
- Size: Teddy is 14 inches; bunny is 11 inches. Choose the bunny for easier handling by small hands and portability; choose the teddy for a more substantial cuddle partner.
- Softness: Bunny features ultra-soft, textured fabric that's a sensory delight; teddy is soft and squishy but not highlighted as exceptionally soft. If maximum softness matters, pick the bunny.
- Style: Teddy is a classic, timeless choice; bunny is modern and gender-neutral with a trendy seafoam color. Consider your nursery decor and personal style. Think about whether you want a traditional keepsake or a contemporary decor piece.
Product facts
- Snuggables Teddy – 14″: The Snuggables Teddy is 14 inches tall and designed for toddlers and young kids, with a soft, squishy body and lovable expression. Its larger size makes it a great cuddle buddy for older babies and toddlers, but it might be too big for a newborn's first weeks.
Snuggables Teddy – 14″ - Putty Seafoam Bunny – 11″: The Putty Seafoam Bunny is 11 inches tall and made from super-soft, textured fabric in a trendy seafoam color. Its smaller size and ultra-soft fabric make it ideal for newborns and babies who love to touch and hold their comfort toy.
Putty Seafoam Bunny – 11″
Which one is right for your baby?
Best for
- Parents who want a modern, gender-neutral plush that's ultra-soft for newborns
- Families looking for a compact comfort toy that's easy to carry in a diaper bag
Not for
- Parents who prefer a classic, larger teddy bear for toddlers who need a bigger cuddle buddy
